I Wrote ‘Music Is Dead’ Back in 1999

While digging up the logo I shared with you yesterday, I uncovered this article I wrote back in June 1999 for an internet magazine lasting all of 2 issues. It was pre-blog, and every article was coded by hand. I know – Dark Ages.

I found it an interesting read both for how much has changed and how the ideas I discuss in here have stuck with me.

Enjoy this trip in the Way-Back Machine.

Music is dead, slowly it is becoming another casualty of electronic technology along side carbon paper and the sword. Each day the global network of computers becomes a greater opponent to traditional music retail and distribution channels. This causes some problems, not only for music retailers but also the record companies, currently focusing 80% of their resources on the manufacturing and distribution of atoms. The web is slowly making an entire infrastructure obsolete. Quick moving upstarts like Goodnoise and Mp3.com are taking advantage of the web’s cost-cutting opportunities by splitting their profits 50/50 with the artist, compared to the 13% artists receive in standard contracts.

This new paradigm asks the question, ‘who needs the record companies and all their middle men between the artist and the fan?’ What is preventing every musician from setting up an ecommerce website and accepting transactions on a per track basis?

Or artists could promote a subscription-based model were fans pay a fee upfront, then receive access to downloadable tracks as they’re released, in addition to deals on tickets and other merchandise.

Artists sites are then not only the clearinghouse for all things related to the artist; tour dates, interviews, fan chats, but also the distribution channel and even a streaming audio / video channel for all Brian Eno all the time.

The European Imperatur MusicTrial study found that users preferred streaming over downloading audio 12 to 1 anyway.

The combination of on-demand streaming with the speed of tomorrow’s bandwidth could easily eliminate the need to archive audio onto a CD by bringing the ability to access any artist, any track, at any time.

With tools like Shoutcast and legislation designed to open low frequency FM waves to consumers, it is plausible that the future will not be about access to 500+ channels, but rather about 1 channel, yours. Plug a low cost FM transmitter up to you home PC, rip you favorite tracks to mp3 and press play. Suddenly your entire cd collection is accessible seamlessly from your car, office, home, and walkman. Time to upload the cd’s and throw out all the broken jewel cases , discs, and inserts.

At a time when college students are purchasing 17 GB hard drives to support 20 track mp3 collections, dubbing a cd onto cassette for a friend seems archaic, it’s much easier to simply email the track across campus. Yet in both situations the branding and visual recognition of the artist and the collection of work is nil. The only visual difference between a Too Much Joy mp3 and a Pan_sonic mp3 is the name of the file, which can be easily changed. Recorded music while entering the ethereal datasphere and leaving the corporeal realm behind, is also leaving behind the visual identification and marketing mechanisms used to promote music and create demand. Leaving in limbo the future of music promotion and all those who shift radio-friendly units.

Though the age of assembly lines and uniformity is decades behind us and each web portal worth its IPO has a customization feature, recorded music is still designed to sound identical each time it is replayed. This leads to the overplayed song, annoyance, and physical nausea. The answer lies in generative music.

Generative music allows the musician to compose like an urban planner, designating themes and setting limitations, making the broad strokes.

The music then finds its own path through the instruments, tones and frequencies designated, creating an ever evolving song. Each track develops its own storyline, its own characters, and its own climax, continuously a part of the ambience until it stopped (considering no two playbacks are identical, ‘paused’ may more accurate). When restarted the music has the same feel, but the storyline has changed, creating a role playing game for your ears.

UPDATE Oct 2008: Giles Bowkett’s Archaeopteryx may be this system I describe. Very cool.
(his presentation from RubyFringe)

Goodbye BlogDigger, Hello AmigoFish

There’s been a problem since the dawn of podcasting – how to find interesting, new things to listen to.

For the past year, my strategy: subscribe to the notoriously noisy BlogDigger for say, a day or so then frantically unsubscribe – the phrase “drink from the firehose” seems appropriate here. Listen to everything over the next 3 weeks, toss out 98% hay, keep the 2% needle.

Highly inefficient. Unfortunately, nothing better existed.

Until a couple weeks ago when Dave Slusher unveiled AmigoFish. Think Netflix for podcasts – rate what you’ve listened to thus far, have the rest of the world find good stuff you’ve missed.

Thus far, I’ve found the fantastic smallworldpodcast interview with Gallagher and noticed Smart City Radio (highly recommended by Joe Urban) is now available via RSS.

From my predictions – there’s a good mix of music, tech, public radio, audio blogs, and stuff less easily definable. These are all good things.

Blogdigger has been wiped from my aggregator. I don’t expect it back ever. AmigoFish is my new friend.

The oddest thing about my experience with AmigoFish?

Everytime I skim the list, I think, “Dave thinks I should listen to this”. Now, that’s no more true with these podcasts than it is with books at Amazon or films at Netflix – but it makes me feel better about AmigoFish than those other places.

UPDATE: AmigoFish adds RSS Prediction Feeds. I knew AmigoFish wouldn’t be useful until it had prediction feeds – I didn’t think it’d turn into my favorite ‘podcast’ in under a week.

Published
Categorized as Podcast

CDs for Good and Not Evil

Now that the Sony rootkit fiasco is behind us. Here’s a selection of CDs that support a good cause and won’t destroy your computer. Just in time for Christmas.

Hey Dan Klass, when do I add The Bitterest Pill Vol. One to this list?

UPDATE 12 Dec 2005: Dan’s taking orders – definitely a steal at $10.

A Podcaster’s Christmas List

It’s the holiday shopping season and I thought it’d be useful to pull together a quick list of computer gear and accessories for the beginning podcaster. Things that would put the best foot forward and provide a good foundation to grow and expand…or not.

Anyway, I was pretty surprised at how low the final price was for all the gear (less than $2,000), and that if you already have a computer with an audio recording application, it’s less than $100 for the mic and cables to get you started. Amazing.

Happy Holidays.

Oh, and send me the podcast if you pull one together this holiday season.

Sex And Podcasting Replaced With 43Folders

I got word this weekend that Mike O’Connor has closed up shop on this community podcasting site – Sex and Podcasting. I’ll miss S&P – haven’t listened to the Geezercast, and love the premise. This means there’s an opening on my gPod.

No worries, it was quickly filled by Merlin Mann’s 43Folders podcast. Merlin had me laughing with tears while on the freeway this afternoon with his Telephone made of Human Ass and Weekly Wrapup 2005-10-21.

Published
Categorized as Podcast

Who Are Garrick’s Favorite Podcasters?

Funny you should ask. I’ve added a new page to the site – gPod – Garrick’s Must Listen Podcasters. These are the podcasters that make my day. The ones that work my braincells, get me thinking, and remind me why podcasting is so much better than broadcast radio.

Like the other pages on this site, this one will probably change with my mood and theirs. Though, if you’re looking for a good tried-and-true listen – you can’t go wrong with someone in this list.

Published
Categorized as Podcast

Multiple Languages, Same Message – A Reason for a Comment-Cast

When I was developing WP-iPodCatter, it seemed straight-forward enough to tie WordPress’ enclosure detection with the Comments RSS feed to create a comment podcast, or comment-cast.

I didn’t have a personal need for this feature (so it’s not as fully developed as the others) but I thought it’d be neat and it was easy to do.
Plus, the thought of a podcast with distributed hosting, on topic, created by fans of another podcast seemed like an interesting way to bring the threaded comments to audio.

Then, listening to Mike’s latest Sex and Podcasting, Katrina – multi-language podcasts, I realized that’s not the interesting bit.

Here’s the scenario, I publish a podcast. You take it, translate it, record it into a language you know well, and republish it as a comment to the original.

Subscribing to the comment feed will automatically deliver the translated files as fast as they’re published.

Could be helpful. Could cause more and bloodier wars.

Published
Categorized as Podcast

WP-iPodCatter Now v1.0

I’ve cleaned up a few things based on the feedback from the 0.9a version, and tweaked a couple more things. Decided “0.9” wasn’t as round a version as I’d like and v1.0 felt better.

The Biggest Changes:
– Comment-cast is now a checkbox option (there were some problems with it being supported on earlier versions of PHP)
– The non-iTunes Channel-level Category tag can now be set.
– All the iTunes categories are listed in the plugin, now more digging around for that PDF.
– all the other stuff you loved from 0.9a

Download WP-iPodCatter v1.0